8.0
rating
Ludopedia
8.0
rating
BGG
Our Verdict
HIGHLY RECOMMENDED
Essential for those seeking more layers of malice and tension in the duel. The game becomes more strategic and cruel.
Highlights
- Deepens the Hunter's investigation
- New evasive tricks for the Witch
- Expands bluffing possibilities
- Preserves the base game's essence
Keep in mind
- Moderate language dependency
- Requires base game to play
Rules manual not indexed yet
Upload the PDF rulebook to ask questions about this game with AI.
About the game
What you do in a play session
If you're already a fan of the psychological tension in Pagan: Fate of Roanoke, get ready, because Trials of Old is here to turn up the heat. This first content pack isn't just an 'extra'—it's an upgrade that deepens the cat-and-mouse dynamic between the Hunter and the Witch, placing a heavy emphasis on the investigative side of the game.
For those playing as the Hunter, the expansion introduces new tools for scrutiny. You now have more intense methods to tighten the noose and unmask the Witch with greater precision. It's that 'I've almost got you' feeling taken to a whole new level. On the flip side, the Witch isn't just sitting ducks. She gains new tricks up her sleeve, allowing her to be even more evasive, deceiving the Hunter with clever maneuvers to avoid detection and, crucially, accelerate the completion of her sinister ritual.
The content is lean and focused: 16 new cards for the Hunter and 16 for the Witch. These additions shift the game's mathematics, forcing both sides to rethink their hand management strategies and how they approach deduction. The tension rises because the bluffing possibilities expand, making every move riskier and every revelation more impactful. It's the perfect expansion for those who feel they've mastered the basic mechanics and want extra layers of complexity and malice in their confrontation.
One important note: since the game relies on card text, keep an eye on the language barrier. If you're not fluent in English, you might need translations or auxiliary spreadsheets to ensure you don't miss any details of the new powers. Ultimately, Trials of Old transforms the hunt into an even more cruel and rewarding game of psychological chess.
For those playing as the Hunter, the expansion introduces new tools for scrutiny. You now have more intense methods to tighten the noose and unmask the Witch with greater precision. It's that 'I've almost got you' feeling taken to a whole new level. On the flip side, the Witch isn't just sitting ducks. She gains new tricks up her sleeve, allowing her to be even more evasive, deceiving the Hunter with clever maneuvers to avoid detection and, crucially, accelerate the completion of her sinister ritual.
The content is lean and focused: 16 new cards for the Hunter and 16 for the Witch. These additions shift the game's mathematics, forcing both sides to rethink their hand management strategies and how they approach deduction. The tension rises because the bluffing possibilities expand, making every move riskier and every revelation more impactful. It's the perfect expansion for those who feel they've mastered the basic mechanics and want extra layers of complexity and malice in their confrontation.
One important note: since the game relies on card text, keep an eye on the language barrier. If you're not fluent in English, you might need translations or auxiliary spreadsheets to ensure you don't miss any details of the new powers. Ultimately, Trials of Old transforms the hunt into an even more cruel and rewarding game of psychological chess.
Expansion for
Published additional content
Gallery
Box and component photos
Tap any photo to open fullscreen. Photos submitted by the community or publisher.
Best player count
BGG community vote
2
BEST
Soundtrack
Ambience suggested by Melodice
Loading playlist...
Where to Buy
Prices monitored daily
Finding best prices...
Prices unavailable at this time.
Price history — last 6 months (lowest new offer)
Alert enabled!
Join the BoardGamesBot deals group
Get the best board game deals every day — without message spam.
Join the WhatsApp groupGame details
Mechanics, categories, families and credits
Mechanics
Categories
Families
Publisher
Wyrmgold GmbH, Capstone Games, Evrikus, HIT Games, Lucky Duck Games, Maldito Games, Rexhry, Super Meeple
Designer
Kåre Storgaard, Kasper Kjær Christiansen
Artist
Lisa Forsch, Maren Gutt
Community
Data from BoardGameGeek
Frequently Asked Questions
Quick answers before you buy
Do I need the base game to play?
Yes, this is a content pack (expansion), so you must own Pagan: Fate of Roanoke to use these cards.
What exactly comes in the box?
The pack contains 32 cards in total: 16 for the Hunter and 16 for the Witch.
Does the game become much harder?
Complexity increases slightly because there are more move and bluffing options, but the core logic remains the same.
Is it recommended for beginners?
I suggest learning the base game first. Save Trials of Old for when you want to add more spice to your matches.
Is the language a problem?
Since there is text on the cards, if you aren't fluent in English, you'll need a translation to fully enjoy the new abilities.