Shallow Regrets: Lingering Remorse

Button Shy · Board game · 2025
2–4 · best 4 15 min Weight 1.3/5
7.0 rating Ludopedia
7.3 rating BGG
Buy
7.0 rating Ludopedia
7.3 rating BGG
Our Verdict
RECOMMENDED

If you love fishing with a dash of horror, this game will hook you with excitement.

Highlights
  • Persistent effects that shift the flow
  • Adds a fourth player option
  • Lightweight expansion, easy to set up
  • Horror theme with a touch of humor
Keep in mind
  • Short playtime may not satisfy those craving longer sessions
  • Requires constant awareness of ongoing effects
Rules manual not indexed yet Upload the PDF rulebook to ask questions about this game with AI.

About the game

What you do in a play session

Shallow Regrets: Lingering Remorse is the 6‑card expansion that comes into play once you’ve got the 18‑card base game. The new creatures are a touch sinister, with effects that stay active until you choose to exhaust them. That means instead of just grabbing a fish and moving on, you have to plan each fishing run around the lingering effects that are still on the table. The expansion adds six extra “shoals,” which you mix with the main deck and deal out so each player gets six cards (eight if a fourth player is in the mix). The ongoing mechanic turns the expansion cards into real obstacles that shift the game’s flow each round. If you like games where strategy evolves over time, you’re in for a treat. Plus, the ability to add a fourth player brings more rivalry and chaos to the fishing frenzy. The components are simple—just cards, no extra pieces—so it’s compatible with the Print & Play version, letting you print at home and dive in without breaking the bank. The game lasts about 15 minutes, perfect for quick sessions or as a warm‑up before a larger gathering. The learning curve is shallow, but the persistent effects demand constant attention. Though the components are just cards, the variety of creatures gives a visual charm reminiscent of a pocket horror book. If you already own the base game, the expansion can be played on its own, but the real fun comes when you mix the two together. Bottom line: if you want a fast, horror‑themed game with a dash of unpredictability, this expansion will give your fishing arsenal a fun upgrade.

Best player count

BGG community vote

2–4 players
2 REC
3 BEST
4 BEST

Where to Buy

Prices monitored daily

Finding best prices...

Game details

Mechanics, categories, families and credits

Families

Game: Shallow Regrets Players: Expansions Changing Player Count Series: Wallet & Box Micro Games (Button Shy) Theme: Fishing / Angling
Publisher Button Shy
Designer Judson Cowan
Artist Judson Cowan

Community

Data from BoardGameGeek

1,387owners
33wishlist
8want to play

Frequently Asked Questions

Quick answers before you buy

6 questions
How long does a game last?
About 15 minutes, perfect for quick sessions.
How many players can play?
2 to 4 players, with support for a fourth player thanks to the expansion.
What is the complexity level?
Low, easy to learn, but ongoing effects require constant attention.
What components are needed?
Just cards; no extra pieces, making it easy to set up and print.
Does the expansion work alone or does it need the base game?
Works best when combined with the 18‑card base, but can be played on its own.
Who is this game for?
For those who enjoy fast, horror‑themed card games with unexpected strategic twists.