Our Verdict
HIGHLY RECOMMENDED
If you love crazy faction mash‑ups and a good laugh, this expansion hits the spot.
Highlights
- Totally unexpected combos
- Contagious humor
- High replay value
Keep in mind
- Light learning curve
- Some cards feel a bit unbalanced
Rules manual not indexed yet
Upload the PDF rulebook to ask questions about this game with AI.
About the game
What you do in a play session
Smash Up: What Were We Thinking? bursts onto the table like a wild flashback to the early days of the series, reviving that "what crazy combo will we get today?" feeling. The expansion lets you mash together off‑the‑wall factions – from cuddly teddy bears to rock‑star grandmas, zombie musicians to explorer dinosaurs – creating duels that feel like a delirious dream. Each player builds a deck from the expansion cards and the core Smash Up set, picking the combos they want to test. During play you play cards to gain influence in board areas, aiming to have the majority or the highest influence at round’s end. The Take‑That mechanic ensures no one stays comfortable, as cards can sabotage opponents at any moment, sparking laughs and surprise. Hand management and deck construction add strategic depth, while open drafting lets everyone see the options and pick together, keeping the game flowing. Variable set‑up means each game starts differently, boosting replayability. The goal is simple: dominate areas, score points, and most importantly, enjoy the most bizarre combos you can pull off. If you love humor, creativity, and games that never feel the same, this expansion will make you ask, "What were we thinking?" – and the answer will be "more crazy cards, please!"
Gallery
Box and component photos
Tap any photo to open fullscreen. Photos submitted by the community or publisher.
Best player count
BGG community vote
2
BEST
3
BEST
4
OK
Soundtrack
Ambience suggested by Melodice
Loading playlist...
Where to Buy
Prices monitored daily
Finding best prices...
Prices unavailable at this time.
Price history — last 6 months (lowest new offer)
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability subject to change.
Alert enabled!
Join the BoardGamesBot deals group
Get the best board game deals every day — without message spam.
Join the WhatsApp groupGame details
Mechanics, categories, families and credits
Mechanics
Categories
Families
Publisher
Alderac Entertainment Group, Hobby World, IELLO, Pegasus Spiele, uplay.it edizioni
Designer
Paul Peterson
Community
Data from BoardGameGeek
4,345owners
412wishlist
81want to play
Frequently Asked Questions
Quick answers before you buy
How many players can join?
2 to 4 players, just like the base game.
How long does a game take?
About 45 minutes, depending on player familiarity.
What is the game’s complexity?
Light to moderate (BGG weight 2.3/5), easy to learn yet offers strategic depth.
Do I need any extra components?
Only the core Smash Up set; the expansion adds new cards and factions.
Who is this game best suited for?
Fans of humor, crazy combos, and quick, replayable games with friends.