Cover of the game What Were You Thinking?

What Were You Thinking?

Wizards of the Coast · Board game · 1998
Ludopedia
6.5 Ludopedia
BoardGameGeek
6.9 BoardGameGeek
Players
4–10 · best 6, 7
Play Time
30 min
Weight
Weight 1.2/5
Year
Year 1998
Minimum age
Minimum age 10+
Buy
6.5 rating Ludopedia
6.9 rating BoardGameGeek
Our Verdict
RECOMMENDED

Perfect for those who love party games focused on social interaction and table reading. The game shines by forcing everyone to guess each other's thought processes, sparking hilarious debates. It’s a light, fast-paced experience that guarantees a good time, as long as you don't take the penalty track too seriously.

Highlights
  • Extremely fun social dynamic
  • Easy to learn and teach
  • Supports large player counts
  • Generates constant conversation and laughter
Keep in mind
  • Can be frustrating for those who hate elimination
  • Totally depends on the group's vibe
Rules manual not indexed yet Upload the PDF rulebook to ask questions about this game with AI.

About the game

What you do in a play session

If you pride yourself on being the smartest in the room, prepare to be humbled! In What Were You Thinking?, the secret isn't about being factually correct, but rather being in sync with the collective mind of your group. Forget trivia knowledge; here, what matters is predicting how your friends will answer. The gameplay is straightforward: a player reads a question, and everyone writes down their answer. If your answer matches the majority, you're safe. But if you’re the only one thinking outside the box, get ready to climb the dreaded penalty track. It's a hilarious exercise in guessing other people's thought processes, often leading to moments where everyone asks, 'What were you thinking?!'. The game flows quickly and chaotically, making it perfect for breaking the ice at any gathering. The tension rises as the penalty track progresses, as the person who hits the top is eliminated, leaving the survivors as the game's winners. It’s the kind of game that doesn't demand deep strategy, but rather a good dose of table reading and, of course, the audacity to justify absurd answers. It supports large groups, making it an excellent choice for parties where conversation is just as important as the game itself. If you enjoy games where social interaction is the main engine and you don't mind being the 'odd one out' for having peculiar taste, this title will guarantee plenty of laughs and debates about your friends' sanity. It’s the ultimate proof that sometimes, thinking like the majority is the only way to survive a game night.

Best player count

BGG community vote

4–10 players
4 REC
5 BEST
6 BEST
7 BEST
8 BEST
9 REC
10 REC

Where to Buy

Prices monitored daily

Finding best prices...

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability subject to change.

Game details

Mechanics, categories, families and credits

Categories

Publisher Wizards of the Coast
Designer Richard Garfield

Community

Data from BoardGameGeek

303owners
91wishlist
23want to play

Frequently Asked Questions

Quick answers before you buy

6 questions
Is the game suitable for children?
Yes, the questions are simple and accessible, making it great for family play.
Do I need to be good at trivia to win?
Not at all! The game doesn't reward knowledge, but rather your ability to predict what your friends will answer.
How long does a game take?
It's quite fast, usually around 30 minutes, perfect for filling gaps during game night.
What happens if I get eliminated?
You are out of the round, but since the game is fast, a new one starts quickly where you can seek revenge.
Does it work well with the maximum number of players?
Yes, the more people, the more chaotic and fun the game becomes, as the majority becomes harder to predict.
Do I need any extra components?
Just paper and pens for each player, in case you don't want to use the voting tokens if they are worn out.

Other Games You'll Like

Based on mechanics and theme

6 games