If you enjoy two-player games with plenty of direct interaction, strategy, and a noir mafia theme, With a Smile & a Gun is an excellent choice! It puts you in the shoes of Prohibition-era gang leaders, where every dice draft decision is a small psychological duel. It's a tense, intelligent game that rewards forward-thinking, perfect for those who appreciate a good cerebral confrontation.
thumb_up
Highlights
check_circle
Tense and strategic duel
check_circle
Engaging mafia theme
check_circle
Clever dice drafting
check_circle
Direct, malicious interaction
check_circle
Impactful decisions
warning_amber
Keep in mind
report_problem
Best with 2 players
report_problem
Can be punishing
report_problem
Requires tactical focus
upload_file
Rules manual not indexed yetUpload the PDF rulebook to ask questions about this game with AI.
info
About the game
What you do in a play session
Inspired by Al Capone's famous quote, "You can get pretty far in life with a smile, but you can get a lot farther with a smile and a gun," With a Smile & a Gun plunges you headfirst into the Prohibition-era underworld. Here, you and your rival take on the roles of criminal gang leaders, battling for control over the city's illicit businesses. The game is a true dance of intrigue and sneakiness, where the goal is always to be one step ahead of your opponent, whether by sending the police to their businesses or leveraging your network's abilities. You need to know when to go all-out and when to lay low.
The core mechanic is an intelligent dice-drafting and area-majority system. Each round, thirteen dice are rolled, forming a pool of options. Each player then drafts two dice: one for movement around the city, which is used to spread your influence, and another for a specific action. The clever twist is that, often, you'll draft a die not because you need it, but because your opponent does – pure cunning! After three rounds of drafting, one of the five non-player characters (NPCs) enters the scene, using the leftover die for their own movement and impacting the game in a unique way. The player who attracted the least attention, meaning the one with the lowest sum of action dice, gets a special 'scheming' action. Then, majorities of influence in each district are scored. After three rounds, the player with the most points claims victory and control of the city. Get ready for a tense duel full of tough decisions!
photo_library
Gallery
Box and component photos
11 photos · from the community
01 / 11
Tap any photo to open fullscreen. Photos submitted by the community or publisher.
groups
Best player count
BGG community vote
1–2 players
1
BEST
2
BEST
BestRecommendedWorks
music_note
Soundtrack
Ambience suggested by Melodice
music_noteLoading playlist...
sell
Where to Buy
Prices monitored daily
shopping_cartFinding best prices...
US$
infoPrices unavailable at this time.
Price history — last 6 months (lowest new offer)
notifications_active
Alert enabled!
Join the BoardGamesBot deals group
Get the best board game deals every day — without message spam.
Crowdfunding: KickstarterDigital Implementations: TabletopiaHistory: Prohibition in the USAMechanism: Dice DraftingTheme: Mystery / Crime
businessPublisherSubsurface Games, SPIEL DAS! Verlag
editDesignerAmanda Vallerand
paletteArtistJustin Lanjil
groups_2
Community
Data from BoardGameGeek
727owners
139wishlist
17want to play
quiz
Frequently Asked Questions
Quick answers before you buy
6 questions
How many players can play With a Smile & a Gun? expand_more
The game is primarily designed for 2 players, offering an intense and strategic duel experience.
What is the average playtime for a game session? expand_more
A game of With a Smile & a Gun typically lasts between 30 and 45 minutes, making it ideal for quick and engaging sessions.
What is the complexity level of the game? expand_more
It's considered a medium-complexity game (BGG weight 2.46/5). The rules are accessible, but strategic decisions have depth, especially in dice drafting and area control.
Does the game rely heavily on luck due to dice usage? expand_more
While it uses dice, luck is mitigated by the drafting mechanic. The strategy lies in how you choose and use the available dice, often taking what your opponent needs more than you do.
What is the main objective of the game? expand_more
The objective is to accumulate the most victory points at the end of three rounds by controlling the majority of city districts and managing your reputation to have the lowest sum of action dice.
Who is With a Smile & a Gun recommended for? expand_more
It's highly recommended for fans of 2-player games who enjoy direct confrontation, tactical strategy, mafia/crime themes, and mechanics like dice drafting and area control.