Cover of the game None But Heroes

None But Heroes

The Gamers, Multi-Man Publishing · Board game · 2011
Ludopedia
— Ludopedia
BoardGameGeek
8.2 BoardGameGeek
Players
2 · best 2
Play Time
60 min
Weight
Weight 3.8/5
Year
Year 2011
Minimum age
Minimum age 15+
Buy · from US$ 76.83
— rating Ludopedia
8.2 rating BoardGameGeek
Our Verdict
HIGHLY RECOMMENDED

None But Heroes is a feast for period wargame lovers who want a historical simulation that doesn't get bogged down in excessive rules. The 'Line of Battle' system is fluid, stripping away bureaucracy to focus on pure tactics. It's an intense duel and a must-have for American Civil War fans seeking realism and strategic depth.

Highlights
  • Fluid and fast-paced game system
  • Top-tier historical research
  • Varied and modular scenarios
  • Excellent simulation of green troops
Keep in mind
  • Requires dedication to learn the rules
  • Exclusive two-player duel experience
  • High complexity for absolute beginners
Rules manual not indexed yet Upload the PDF rulebook to ask questions about this game with AI.

About the game

What you do in a play session

If you're a fan of military history and have always wondered if you could have performed better than McClellan or Lee at the Battle of Antietam, None But Heroes is the game for you. This title kicks off MMP's 'Line of Battle' series, introducing a system that finally ditches the endless paperwork and bureaucratic fire phases to focus on what matters: tactical battlefield action. The game recreates the bloodiest day in American history with impressive realism, integrating combat directly into movement to make the experience dynamic and intense.

What truly shines here is the deep historical research. You won't find generic units; the game details the strength, equipment, and even the 'greenness' of the troops. You know those units that barely knew how to load their muskets? They are there, and understanding how to manage those inexperienced troops against battle-hardened veterans completely changes how you plan your moves. The components are top-notch, with maps covering crucial conflict points like the Cornfield and the Sunken Road, allowing you to play everything from small learning scenarios to full two-day campaigns.

For the Union player, the challenge is to overcome McClellan's command limitations and find a way to break the Confederate resistance. Meanwhile, the Confederate player needs to be surgical, using the elan and determination of their limited troops to counterattack and stall the enemy advance. It's a pure duel game where every decision counts and the tension is constant. If you're looking for a wargame that respects history but also understands that players want to play, not just read rulebooks full of bureaucracy, None But Heroes delivers a top-tier tactical experience. Ready your dice and your strategy, because the fate of Sharpsburg is literally in your hands.

Best player count

BGG community vote

Duel · 2 players
2 BEST

Where to Buy

Prices monitored daily

Finding best prices...

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability subject to change.

Game details

Mechanics, categories, families and credits

Families

Cities: Sharpsburg (MD, USA) Players: Two-Player Only Games Series: Line of Battle (MMP)
Publisher The Gamers, Multi-Man Publishing
Designer Dean Essig
Artist Nicolás Eskubi

Community

Data from BoardGameGeek

714owners
168wishlist
61want to play

Frequently Asked Questions

Quick answers before you buy

6 questions
Is the game too long?
A standard session takes about 60 minutes, though larger scenarios can take longer if you play the full two-day campaign.
Can I play it solo?
The game is specifically designed for two players. While you could play it solo, the experience is optimized for a head-to-head duel.
Is it hard to learn?
With a weight of 3.76, it is geared towards players who already have some experience with hex-and-counter wargames.
What are the main components?
You get two large maps, five counter sheets, rulebooks, charts/tables booklets, and two 6-sided dice.
Does it cover the whole war?
No, the focus is specifically on the Battle of Antietam in Sharpsburg, Maryland.
Do I need prior historical knowledge?
It's not mandatory, but the included historical notes greatly enrich the experience for those who like to understand the real-life context of the units.

Other Games You'll Like

Based on mechanics and theme

8 games