Cover of the game Sherlock: El mayordomo

Sherlock: El mayordomo

GDM Games, ABACUSSPIELE, Broadway Toys LTD · Board game · 2019
Ludopedia
— Ludopedia
BoardGameGeek
6.8 BoardGameGeek
Players
1–8 · best 3
Players
Solo
Play Time
60 min
Weight
Weight 1.9/5
Year
Year 2019
Minimum age
Minimum age 10+
Buy · from US$ 7.95
— rating Ludopedia
6.8 rating BoardGameGeek
Our Verdict
RECOMMENDED

Sherlock: The Butler is a compact and intense deduction game, perfect for those who love solving mysteries with friends. The limited card mechanic creates a clever cooperative dynamic, where every discard decision can be the difference between success and failure. It is a short, focused experience ideal for a casual game night.

Highlights
  • Engaging investigation mechanics
  • Portable and fast-paced
  • Great value for money
  • Essential teamwork
Keep in mind
  • One-time play experience
  • Relies on good communication
  • Can be frustrating if the group lacks synergy
Rules manual not indexed yet Upload the PDF rulebook to ask questions about this game with AI.

About the game

What you do in a play session

If you enjoy a good mystery and want to feel like a real detective without leaving your table, Sherlock: The Butler is your next challenge. In this Q System game, the setting is tense: the famous butler from Milwaukee has been found dead, and the burning question is whether we are dealing with a suicide or a cold-blooded murder. With a deck of only 32 cards, the game tasks you and your friends with investigating clues, analyzing facts, and, most importantly, managing limited information.

The dynamic is straightforward: each player holds cards and, on their turn, must decide whether to reveal a clue to the group or discard it. The catch is that you cannot show your hand, only read specific parts of the text. This creates a delightful tension where you must choose what is essential to the case and what is a mere distraction—after all, discarding vital clues costs precious points at the end. Communication is limited, so teamwork is crucial to piecing together the puzzle.

Once all cards have been processed, the group enters the debate phase. It is time to lay the cards on the table, discuss what everyone remembers, and build the final theory to answer the questionnaire. The game is fast, focused, and demands great attention to detail. It is perfect for those nights when you want a game that doesn't take up the whole table but still offers a great intellectual challenge. As an investigation game, the experience is one-off: once you solve the mystery, the surprise is gone, but the journey there is intense and highly entertaining. Grab your magnifying glass and call your friends, because the butler's mystery won't solve itself!

Best player count

BGG community vote

1–8 players
1 REC
2 BEST
3 BEST
4 BEST
5 OK
6 OK
7 OK
8 OK

Where to Buy

Prices monitored daily

Finding best prices...

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability subject to change.

Game details

Mechanics, categories, families and credits

Families

Misc: Limited Replayability Organizations: Board Games Association of Creators in Spain (LUDO) Series: Q System – Sherlock (GDM Games)
Publisher GDM Games, ABACUSSPIELE, Broadway Toys LTD, Fantasmagoria, Geek Attitude Games, Geekach LLC, Lifestyle Boardgames Ltd, MS Edizioni
Designer Dani Seguí, Eugeni Castaño, Josep Izquierdo Sánchez, Martí Lucas Feliu
Artist Amelia Sales

Community

Data from BoardGameGeek

701owners
24wishlist
3want to play

Frequently Asked Questions

Quick answers before you buy

6 questions
Can it be played solo?
Yes! The game works well both solo and in a group, although group discussion is the highlight of the experience.
How long does a game last?
It is quite fast, lasting about 60 minutes on average, depending on the group's discussion speed.
Can I play it more than once?
Since it is a mystery game, once you know the solution, the surprise is gone. It is designed as a one-time experience.
Do I need any other components?
No, the game comes with just the necessary cards. Everything you need to solve the case is in the deck.
Is it a difficult game?
With a weight of 1.89, it is considered an entry-level game, accessible to beginners but requiring logic and attention.
How many players can play?
The game supports 1 to 8 players, making it very flexible for different group sizes.

Other Games You'll Like

Based on mechanics and theme

8 games